| Year | Winner | School | Sponsor |
| 2019 | Emma Mastruserio | Mercy McAuley High School | Daughter of Joe & Sue Mastruserio |
| 2018 | Taylor Marie Drapp | Mercy McAuley High School | Grandaughter of Joe & Marcia Geraci |
| 2017 | Lucy Milazzo | Mercy High School | Daughter of Charlie & Lisa Milazzo |
| 2016 | Lauren Meese | Notre Dame Academy | Granddaughter of Dave & Sandy Sabatelli |
| 2015 | Nick Rielag | LaSalle High School | Grandson of Dave & Sandy Sabatelli |
| 2014 | Gabrielle Reiff | Seton High School | Granddaughter of Ron and Connie Dalessandro |
